The Impossible Quest: Problems with Diligent Search for Orphan Works
Digital technologies allow unprecedented preservation and sharing of world-wide cultural heritage. Public and private players are increasingly entering the scene with mass digitisation projects that will make this possible. In Europe, legislative action has been taken to allow cultural institutions to include in their online collections copyright works whose owner is either unknown or non-locatable (‘Orphan Works’). However, according to the Orphan Works Directive, cultural institutions need to attempt to locate the owner of a work before using it. This is the so-called ‘Diligent Search’ requirement.
This paper provides an empirical analysis of the conditions under which a Diligent Search can be feasibly carried out. The United Kingdom, the Netherlands, and Italy, all of which have implemented the Orphan Works Directive, have been selected as case-studies. For each jurisdiction, the analysis determines what are the requirements for Diligent Search to locate copyright holders are, what the authoritative sources and databases to be consulted are in practice and, most importantly, to what extent these are freely accessible on line.
The statistical analysis of the accessibility of these sources reveals that a sizeable share of them is not freely accessible online. This makes the consultation of these sources overly burdensome and costly. Therefore, it will be difficult for cultural institutions to clear the rights of their collections while fully complying with the requirements of the legislation.
This article concludes that legislative action, official guidelines, or jurisprudence are needed to establish different legal value of sources for diligent search, with various degrees of optionality depending on data relevance and accessibility.
Marcella Favale, Simone Schroff, and Aura Bertoni, “The Impossible Quest: Problems with Diligent Search for Orphan Works,” Copyright Cortex, accessed October 15, 2019, https://copyrightcortex.org/policy-evidence/the-impossible-quest-problems-with-diligent-search-for-orphan-works.